THAT KIND OF GIRL By Natalie C. Anderson

Dani Young 

I received this book for free from Publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

THAT KIND OF GIRL By Natalie C. AndersonThat Kind of Girl by Natalie C. Anderson
Published by Nancy Paulsen Books on 6/24/25
Genres: Mystery & Detective, Thrillers, Young Adult
Pages: 300
Format: eARC
Source: Publisher
Buy on Amazon
two-stars

Sixteen-year-old amateur sleuth Roxie is shrewd, nimble, cunning, and only a little bit damaged. She also has a real knack for finding things, making her the perfect go-to detective for her rich classmates at St. Margaret when they’re looking to retrieve the things they’ve “lost"— no questions asked. So when queen bee Kirsten Montgomery-Wiggins pays Roxie a hefty sum to track down a mysterious blonde who “stole” her phone, Roxie accepts. Although Kirsten and Roxie have bad blood between them, Roxie could really use the cash. But that same night, Roxie finds Kirsten murdered in her mansion, and police zero in on her as a prime suspect.

On the outskirts of town in a trailer park, Inez, a part-time maid and part-time sex-worker, keeps finding blood everywhere. Crusted in her earring, threaded into her shoelace. She should really toss her shoes so there’s nothing to tie her to the body. How could the night have gone so wrong? She really thought she was working her way to a better life, but now she could be headed to jail if the wrong someone puts two and two together.

Roxie doesn’t know who she’s looking for and Inez doesn’t know who she’s hiding from. But all roads seem to lead to Montgomery House, as Roxie works to clear her own name and Inez attempts to stay one step ahead of the law and the men who hurt her.

Short and Sweet Review

That Kind of Girl follows Roxie someone who prides herself on being a sleuth and finding items for her classmates. When popular classmate Kirsten pays Roxie a lump sum to find someone Roxie agrees to meet with Kirsten to learn more information. When Roxie shows up to Kirstens house she finds her murdered and Roxie becomes the prime suspect. We also have Inez who is a maid and a sex worker and everywhere she looks she finds dried blood and she knows she should get rid of the evidence before someone ties her to the body. Roxie isn’t exactly sure who she’s looking for but all the evidence points to one place and Inez is trying her best to stay one step ahead to avoid capture.

This is a book I didn’t enjoy. We have Roxie who has a reputation for being able to find things hired by popular girl Kirsten. Kirsten wants Roxie to find a girl who could possibly have her phone, when Roxie goes to Kirsten’s house to learn more information she finds Kiersten murdered. Roxie ends up being a suspect because she was in the wrong place at the wrong time and she also has a history with Kirsten. Inez is a maid and also a sex worker and at times I thought this book could be a New Adult just because of that fact and we also got her POV. The plot was okay but I thought it could have been better executed. My biggest problem with this book is that it was trying to come off as something complex but it just made things more confusing. Not only is Roxie trying to solve Kirsten’s murder but her great aunt also left her clues for a scavenger hunt and this was something I didn’t care for, I thought the murder and the Roxie trying to find Inez was enough. Inez also has some dark secrets she’s hiding. I didn’t care for either character, I didn’t connect with them and they sounded too similar to each other.

Overall, I really can’t say much about the book without spoiling it. I just know that this book wasn’t for me. The synopsis made it sound interesting but the book was the opposite and was one I had to push myself to finish.

two-stars

Recommended Posts

SUCH A LUCKY GIRL By Wendy Heard

SHORT AND SWEET REVIEW Such a Lucky Girl combines influencer culture, toxic friendship, jealousy, and supernatural horror into a story that felt both timely and unsettling. The premise immediately caught my attention: Bella has transformed herself into a social media star through her brand of positivity and manifestation, while her former best friend Kerry is left […]

Dani Young 

BLUE BEACH By Karyn Parsons

Short and Sweet Review Blue Beach was a compelling blend of historical fiction and murder mystery that kept me invested from beginning to end. Set in 1929 Santa Monica, the story follows fifteen-year-old Blue Collins, whose family owns Blue Beach, a safe gathering place for Black families during segregation. When Blue and her friend Ben […]

Dani Young 

THE SPIRITUALISTS By Kristin O’Donnell Tubb

Short and Sweet Review The Spiritualists follows Stella, a teenage psychic living in early 1900s New York who survives by performing séances and tarot readings while struggling with the guilt and grief surrounding her sister’s death. When a mysterious boy named Pax invites her to join a secret group of mystics determined to uncover the […]

Dani Young