NEW YEAR’S GRIEVE By Elizabeth Foscue
I received this book for free from Publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
New Year's Grieve by Elizabeth Foscue Published by HarperCollins on 11/17/26
Genres: Mystery & Detective, Thrillers, Young Adult
Pages: 253
Format: eARC
Source: Publisher
Buy on Amazon
Jojo had planned to spend her winter break healing her heart in the surf of the Pacific. Instead, she’s being forced to attend Grandad’s New Year’s birthday at his estate in the snowy North Carolina mountains—along with her whole horrible family, each one competing to be the most insufferable person at the dinner table.
But things are even worse than Jojo had feared. For some ungodly reason, Fritz is here—Fritz, the childhood friend who broke her heart last summer, whom she’s sworn to loathe for all eternity. And, worst of all, he looks great in winter wear.
The trip takes a turn for the tragic when Grandad is found dead. No one else in the snowed-in house suspects foul play, but Jojo knows the truth: Someone here has committed a murder. Now, she just has to figure out who, and murder them back.
And, because the universe hates her, she might need Fritz’s help...
Short and Sweet Review
Jojo would much rather spend her winter break surfing in California than attending her grandfather’s 90th birthday celebration in the snowy mountains of North Carolina. Unfortunately, she’s stuck spending the holidays with her wealthy, dysfunctional family, none of whom seem particularly enjoyable to be around. To make matters worse, Fritz, her childhood friend and ex-boyfriend who broke her heart last summer, is also there. Just when Jojo thinks the weekend couldn’t get any worse, her grandfather is found dead. While everyone else believes it was an accident, Jojo is convinced someone in the house murdered him. With the estate snowed in and a house full of suspects, she decides to investigate, even if it means teaming up with the last person she wants to spend time with.
I was really intrigued by the premise of this book. A snowed-in mansion, a wealthy family full of secrets, a murder mystery, and an exes to lovers storyline sounded like such a fun combination. I also enjoyed the Knives Out and Clue vibes, especially with all the different family members who could potentially be responsible. The family dynamics were entertaining at times, and I liked that everyone had their own personality and secrets. Unfortunately, the biggest problem for me was Jojo. I found her incredibly difficult to like, and while I understand that she’s supposed to be sarcastic and have a complicated relationship with her family, her constant rudeness started getting exhausting. I struggled with the way she treated Fritz in particular, especially when he was genuinely trying to help her. Their relationship had potential, but I never really felt the chemistry or emotional connection I was hoping for. The pacing also didn’t quite work for me. It takes a surprisingly long time for the murder to happen, with much of the first half focused on introducing the family and their various conflicts. I didn’t mind getting to know everyone, but there were so many characters to keep track of that it became a little overwhelming. Once the mystery finally gets going, I wanted more opportunities to actually solve it alongside Jojo. Instead, some of her discoveries felt like they came out of nowhere, and the increasingly outrageous moments made it difficult to know whether the story wanted to be taken seriously or treated as a comedy. I appreciated the attempt at a ridiculous, over the top murder mystery, but I don’t think the humor always landed for me. The final reveal was interesting, but the way everything unfolded left me wanting a little more from the mystery itself.
Overall, New Years Grieve had a fun setup, but the unlikeable protagonist, uneven pacing, and over the top moments kept it from being the entertaining holiday mystery I was hoping for. I liked the setting and the idea of a dysfunctional family trapped together with a killer, but I never became invested enough in Jojo or her relationship with Fritz to really enjoy the story. I think this could have worked better with a little less family drama and more focus on the actual mystery. If you enjoy sarcastic heroines, wealthy families with plenty of secrets, snowed-in murder mysteries, and chaotic holiday gatherings, you might have a better time with this one than I did.